deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
Shop Similar Prints
This Print Not Available
Download Image
JPG, 402×600
more ▶

More from *hiritai

Featured in Groups:

Details

April 23, 2009
54.5 KB
402×600
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 57
Favourites: 851 [who?]

Views: 9,106 (0 today)
Downloads: 168 (0 today)
[x]
:iconhiritai:
So this is the first time I've purposely tried high key. I'll probably enter it in the contest but I'm not sure because I really have no idea what I'm doing XD

As for the critique, I really want to know how I can improve on this technique, rather than composition or whatever else, because this is obviously a first and I really want to work on it. But anything is good, I need to start actively learning rather than picking things up when it suits me. Nothing better to do XD

And as far as the doll goes, because that's why you're really here, lol. I'm still trying to find a place for Mystic. A name and a 'look' and a character. I keep changing it because nothing feels right. Needs to feel right, like the others... but he's not like the others which makes it all a bit difficult.

But anyway. Let me know what you think and how I can change/improve it to be better! 8D
Add a Comment:
 
:iconspekle:
While I do love the way you used the negative space in this piece the subject or focal point itself does not meet the requirement for 'high key'. This creates a great focus point but again, it lacks the intent for a high key piece.

A way to improve high key intent is not to overexpose as most people would think but use high key values. 50% greys and above would be ideal for a black and white piece.

If you still want to have a strong focal point I would use the color or a small quantity of a strong grey (70%+).

Personally I love the negative space. Negative space is like the new black. One thing I would change is the actual figure value, I would make it lighter. Keep the awesome angle and pose, it be awesome.
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
9 out of 9 deviants thought this was fair.

:iconbloodpennies:
I feel this piece, in terms of what it's meant to represent and in contrast to your body of work is very weak.

The subject is very haphazardly "tossed" into the photo and I actually find there's far too much dead space. It lacks the sort of balance that makes a good photograph.

Looking at this piece I don't see "High-key." High Key is the art of over exposing a photo without losing the detail. There are spots you've washed things out and the rest of you photo isn't over exposed really. It's very splotchy in places, like the shoulder of his coat and the collar on the left side (his right). It would appear as if you've relied far too heavily on photoshop to achieve the desired effect as opposed to trying to get there about 90% with your camera and lighting, and using an editing program to maybe bump you through that last 10%; and in the end I think it's really only put you half way there.

I think in the end I would very much suggest three things to help you better achieve better results in this photo.

Less black.
I know that technically dressing your subject in black doesn't affect whether or not a photo is high key, but using a colour or white will make it much easier to achieve what you want and avoid the faded, washed out look Mystic's clothing has in this photo.

Less Dead Space.
It's distracting really, I end up looking at it more than the subject which is a shame since he's such a gorgeous subject.

Less Photoshop.
It really does affect the quality of the photo. The more you can get there "traditionally" and the less with digital editing, I think the better quality your end result will have.
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
40 out of 47 deviants thought this was fair.

The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork

Please sign up or login to post a critique.

love 2 2 joy 1 1 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconpigswearties:
!pigswearties Apr 27, 2009   Photographer
what is high key photograpghy?
Reply
:iconusabusa:
*usabusa Apr 25, 2009  Student General Artist
He looks really good with dark hair! :lol::heart:
Reply
:iconpancake-fairy:
mmm~~~
Mystic.... should have grown up in the Circus~ xD lol~
o3o
Reply
:iconresiniquity:
I think it looks magnificent.
Reply
:iconlamus:
~Lamus Apr 24, 2009  Professional Photographer
Doll is great. Composition of image is awesome! :-)
Reply
:icontiedbylove:
he looks really nice!
Reply
:iconlann-eh:
I don't see Mystic as dark like this.
His blonde hair brought out a tenderness in him that doesn't appear with dark hair, he looks very blank dark haired >.<

But I get what you mean... its hard to assign him a character.
With your other dolls I see the character in them, even in their names.

Maybe Mystic should be a bohemian lol
Goes to renaissance fairs and likes faeries /shrug lol
Reply
:icondm2sleepybean:
I don't have enough words to write a critique... anyways, there is just a bit much ambient light for this photo to work without photoshop(which isn't necessary at all, your efforts can stop at the click of the shutter). so block a small amount of ambient light which allows you to take a slightly longer exposure, or larger aperture...
Reply
:iconhiritai:
I'm not really sure what your advice is, aside from not using photoshop?
Reply
:icondm2sleepybean:
Well yea... you dont have to use photoshopto do this... and this picture in particular could use just a little less background light to over-expose withhout loss in detail...(on the edges there is some excess light causing excess fading. less light and a smaller aperture should help fix this.)
Reply
Add a Comment: